Gave it shot because they had a weekday special for a large 3-topping pizza for 12.99 and it was a great choice! The place looks a little sketchy from the outside, but it's clean inside and smells great when you walk in. It's not a dine-in place, just a pickup/delivery place, which is cool with me because their online ordering was easy to figure out and my pizza was ready right at the quoted pickup time. It was a real seamless experience. More importantly, it tasted really good! I got the garlic butter crust and it was very flavorful and had a great balance of fluffy middle and crispy edges. They don't skimp on the cheese or the toppings and it was exactly the way I ordered it. It smelled so good, my normally polite dog was literally crying because she wanted some (she got a small bite, don't worry). A large is definitely enough for 3-4 people, so you could feed a small family or friend group for under 15. That's pretty dang good. And it's December, so they even put it in a cute holiday themed box! All in all, 5 star experience. I will most definitely be a repeat customer. This is a really solid local pizza joint.

This place is ABSOLUTELY MY NEW AND FOREVER PIZZA SPOT!!!! The garlic parmesan crust meat pizza made with A TON OF CHEESE AND DIFFERENT MEATS WAS AMAZING!!!!! WE ALSO ordered a SUPREME that was just as amazing!!! THEY DO NOT SHORT CHANGE YOU ON INGREDIENTS!!!! Don't hesitate make this your new pizza spot as well!!! They understand that you shouldn't have to order cheese on your pizza it should come with it automatically!!!! Go see Johny

Excellent pizzas made with care. Phenomenal stuffed crust. Actual quality ingredients that feel good in the belly. If you live in GP this is the spot.

We're in town for a few days from Minnesota for some college baseball. We were in the mood for some pizza and my wife found Uncle John's Pizza online, and it seemed to have good reviews. Very well deserved! Probably one of the better pizza's we've had. They are definitely not scared to put the toppings on. Definitely worth the money.

Loved it!! Will definitely come here more often! Everything was delicious & I love how cheesy the pizza was.

Take-out only spot with very fair price and easy to navigate website! Their pizza is SO good! I got a small pizza, garlic butter crust with Alfredo sauce, pepperoni, mushroom, spinach, and onion, not extra sauce or cheese. The cheese was plentiful, soft, tasted great, and made a good stringy but not tough cheese pull. The topping was very generous, fresh, not burnt at all but had little flavorful charring, which is GREAT! The crust was fluffy, just enough thickness, pillowy and very buttery, among the best crust I have had not counting like idk, fancy neapolitan/NY pizza. The sauce is not salty at all and came in perfect amount, but if you order extra cheese maybe order extra sauce because they tend to be light on the sauce in comparison to the very generous amount of toppings and cheese. Honestly I didn't expect it to be this good haha but the pizza was genuinely social-media worthy and tasted great. Will be ordering from them from now on! Also the owner was a nice man, straightforward, no bs, quick and attentive with good customer service. He's running the entire place on his own im pretty sure, so be patient and maybe not call them, their website is so easy to use! Crush red peppers actually have a taste and the entire pizza packets actually taste fresh, and I picked it up super on time and hot!

If happiness came in a box... We LOVED this classic pizza! I don't often use the word, "hefty", to describe food, but The Supreme is exactly that; it's loaded with toppings! The cheese was lightly broiled, provided good coverage to hold the toppings in place, and stringy when pulled apart. One might expect the bottom to be doughy or soggy, but I was pleasantly surprised to find the crust even in the center held up and had a fine layer of crispiness thanks to the garlic butter. Every bite was delicious, including the crust! (I don't eat most crusts.) Try the BBQ sauce, it was a game changer and blended well with the meats. The service was attentive and friendly, and it seemed there was just one person baking and manning the counter. I recommend ordering online to take advantage of their discounts. This was a friend recommendation. They close at 9 PM on weekdays, and 930 PM Friday and Saturday. There aren't any frills here, just a pick up counter and two benches. No beverage machine, no dining area, and no public restroom. Next time I may order a combo with 2 liter to go. Large pizzas now come in holiday boxes perfect for an office party!

My second visit to Uncle John's and taste wise, there isn't any competition. Fresh ingredients and that cheese!!! OMG!!! I got the thin crust because I prefer less dough. Yes, almost half was gone in one sitting.